Why Does My Volleyball Player Serve Well in Practice but Miss in Games?

When a volleyball player serves cleanly in practice but misses in matches, she usually has a pressure-triggered mental block, not a technique problem. Her skill is intact, but under match pressure her nervous system shifts into an involuntary stress response that routines and extra reps often do not change. Training that helps her nervous system get comfortable with discomfort, such as Brainspotting and biofeedback with a mental performance specialist, is typically what improves the mental block. Most athletes need about 15 to 25 sessions, and the work is usually hard during sessions with real relief afterward.

  • Updated on 10/8/26, written by Benjamin Foodman, CMPC, LCSW, CSCS


Ben Foodman is a licensed psychotherapist & Certified Mental Performance Consultant (CMPC) through the Association for Applied Sport Psychology (AASP). He owns his private practice located in Charlotte North Carolina where he specializes in working with athletes to help them overcome mental blocks (the yips), increase mental toughness and improve focus using techniques such as Brainspotting, biofeedback, exercise science and sport psychology. If you are interested in services, use the link here! Enjoy the article below!

A thumbnail image for a blog about mental blocks and how sport psychology can help athletes overcome this issue

 
 
 

Ben Foodman's Training Report logo

 

Is It a Technique Problem or a Mental Block?

If she misses in practice too, it is most likely technique, and her coach should be the first call. If her serve is clean in practice and breaks down only when she is being watched, scored, or playing a match, a mental block is the more likely explanation. Off-court strain, like poor sleep, grades, or high athlete identity (basing her self-worth on how she performs), can also point toward a block.

Coaches are right that many missed serves come from mechanics. An inconsistent toss, a contact point that drifts, or a swing that changes from serve to serve will send the ball long or into the net in any setting. Comparing video of practice serves with match serves is a smart first step, and good coaches do it. But that explanation stops working when the mechanics are fine all week but not in competition.

If she can repeat the serve in the majority of practices, the real question is why the same movement changes only in matches. Research on mental blocks describes a continuum from movement-based breakdowns to pressure-triggered ones, and when pressure scenarios are introduced compared to ‘low-stakes’ practices, this should be the giveaway. Regardless of the athlete or level of competition, our brains respond in a very specific way to pressure.

Missing serves in matches can come from four different problems, and they look the same to a parent watching the game:

  1. She can’t describe why she misses - Her serve is reliable in many situations, but it breaks down when a miss costs her team a point or just randomly throughout the match. This is the classic mental block.

  2. She does not trust her serve - She genuinely does not know where the ball will go, and this can be seen in practice too. She gets nervous because of this and needs technical work first, because no amount of confidence fixes a toss that changes every time.

  3. She is terrified of letting others down - People underestimate the power of social psychology and how the fear of failing others is more often than not, far more terrifying than letting yourself down. This can be because the individual has a high-level of Athlete Identity.

  4. She is exhausted but unaware of how depleted her ‘battery’ is - athletes are masters of dissociation and do not do a good job of taking into account how poor their recovery is. A depleted mental battery will lead to these types of involuntary mental blocks.

Many players have at least one of these issues going on, and it is not uncommon to have all of these happening at once. A simple way to sort it out is to ask her coach to run the same serve under three conditions: unscored, scored with the coach watching, and a game-like drill with a real consequence. If her toss and swing hold up in the first and come apart as the stakes rise, the problem is not her technique. Her technique is how the problem shows up. Another thing parents and coaches can do is if the athlete wears a Whoop strap, they can look at the recovery data to see how the athlete is doing from an energy standpoint. Typically, poor HRV scores are associated with poor mental states which can lead to these types of mental blocks.

 

A volleyball on a court

 

Does It Matter When in the Match She Misses?

Yes. Misses that cluster at her first serve, right after a miss, or at close scores point to pressure, not technique, because a technique problem shows up at any score. The timing also shows what triggers her stress response.

 
 

We tend to think of sports as a separate issue from traditional life stress. But young folks in their late teens and early twenties unconsciously are using sports as a canvas to create a sense of stability and self-worth when it comes to their identity, otherwise known as athlete identity. Research in this area has shown that Athlete Identity can lead to burnout, or other negative mental health or mental performance issues such as mental blocks. This is important when it comes to the ‘when’ mental blocks occur because in my professional experience athletes that are going through the negative symptoms of high athlete identity will often exhibit these symptoms during key parts of their career such as junior year of high school when college scouts show up to competitions, senior year of high school when recruiting is being finalized, or freshmen and sophomore year of college when coaches are starting to look at performance metrics.

Parents and coaches usually notice one of four patterns when these symptoms begin to manifest:

  • She misses her first serve of the match. She has been thinking about that serve since warmups. By the time she gets the ball, she is already experiencing excessive tension. She reports increased heart rate, temperature changes or increased muscle stiffness.

  • One miss leads to another. After a miss, she walks back to the line still thinking about it and ‘locks up’ before she even tosses the ball. She starts to create negative momentum against herself and cannot get out of the cycle.

  • She misses mostly at close scores. Her serve holds up when her team is ahead and falls apart in tight games. The score is what changed and she does not have a predictable system to overcome this new psychological hurdle.

  • She misses all match, even with a big lead. The pressure is no longer tied to big moments. Just being in a match is enough. This usually means the block has been around for a while.

 

Beach volleyball athletes using sport psychology to help overcome their mental blocks

 

Why Don't Routines and Pressure Drills Fix a Serving Mental Block?

Because a serving block is an involuntary stress response, not a focus problem. Routines and pressure drills train focus and skill, which helps a nervous player but does not change how her body reacts under pressure. What usually changes it is nervous system training that helps her get comfortable with discomfort at the service line.

Most advice for this problem, from coaches, websites, and influencer accounts ends up being the same: build a pre-serve routine, take a breath, pick a target, think positive thoughts, and practice serving under pressure. That advice is sound for a player who gets a little nervous. A consistent routine gives her something familiar to do, and pressure drills help practice look more like a match.

A player with a real block is in a different situation. She is not choosing to tighten up at the service line, and she cannot reason her way out of it in the moment. A stress response of this kind is involuntary and limits the parts of the brain that handle deliberate, step-by-step control, which is why Bessel van der Kolk describes the thinking brain losing ground to the body's alarm system under threat. Imagine that your brain is made up of two roommates: the neocortex which would be like a college guidance counselor, and the subcortical brain which would be like a blind-folded alligator. The mental block is created by the alligator, and when you tell that roommate to stop ‘thinking too much’, that part of the brain will have no clue what you are saying.

An infographic on 3 common fixes that backfire on helping volleyball players overcome mental blocks

What I have found over the years dealing with this all of the time is that there are three common fixes can backfire for a player with a block:

  1. Pressure drills with consequences. If every drill adds stakes, she gets more reps of missing under pressure, and the service line starts to feel worse, not better. This is like trying to use a hammer for every problem you have…it may just not be the right tool.

  2. "Stop thinking too much" instructions. Every reminder points her attention at the miss. A player who is already afraid of missing does not need another reason to think about it. But telling athletes they are ‘thinking too much’ is not helpful, actionable, or even the accurate fix.

  3. Pulling her off serving or moving her to underhand. It can be the right short-term call for the team. It also teaches her body that the way to handle the feeling at the line is to avoid it, and avoidance tends to make a block last longer.

What these fixes have in common is that they work on the serve. The block is not in the serve. It is in how her body responds to serving under pressure, and that is what has to be trained. An athlete needs to use tools that focus on the subcortical brain region, not the neocortex.

 

Volleyball athletes using Ben Foodman's mental training skills to overcome mental blocks

 

What Actually Helps a Player Serve Well in Matches Again?

What usually helps is training her nervous system to handle more stress, through methods like Brainspotting and biofeedback with a mental performance specialist, plus daily breathing and recovery work between sessions. The sessions are typically hard while she is in them, with relief afterward. Most athletes need about 15 to 25 sessions, and some need more.

A multi-modal approach is typically the most effective approach. The first part of this approach involves in-person mental coaching that utilizes interventions such as desensitization techniques like EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization & Reprocessing) or Brainspotting, but under the guidance of a professional who has both advanced training and applied experience working with athletes. These individuals typically possess the CMPC certification (Certified Mental Performance Consultant) through the Association for Applied Sport Psychology, graduate degrees in sport psychology, and in some cases also possess mental health licensure. This combination of training allows them to tailor the EMDR and Brainspotting to the athlete’s needs. Ideally, these sessions are done in-person but in some cases where appropriate, they can be done online. Sport psychologists are starting to see the value in utilizing these approaches because there is emerging research that has shown how these types of interventions can help athletes overcome mental blocks in their sport.

An infographic on 3 sport psychology tips to overcome mental blocks

The second part of the approach is the out-of session work that the athlete needs to do. This should involve a combination of specific types of breathworks such as diaphragmatic breathing, biofeedback, and energy management techniques that involve stress-recovery tracking. These practices and interventions need to be integrated into the athlete’s schedule with oversight from a Certified Mental Performance Consultant who has training and advanced knowledge on the autonomic nervous system as well as exercise science protocols. This is because these interventions need to be slowly and methodically integrated in the same way a strength coach uses periodization to help build up an athlete’s physical strength. What I have found is that when athletes are dedicated to the process, it can take them anywhere between 3-4 months to successfully integrate their mental conditioning program into their regimen. Once athletes do this, it significantly reduces the chances that they will experience mental blocks in their sport again. There are several common benefits that athletes report after undergoing this specific mental training protocol:

  • reduced symptoms or complete elimination of the mental block

  • performance anxiety symptoms turn into excitement nerves

  • athletes report increased energy

  • many athletes report experiencing elimination of burnout

  • the athlete’s support system reports that the athlete exhibits behaviors consistent with being comfortable with discomfort

 

A sport psychologist working with a volleyball athletes to help her overcome mental blocks

 

Case Study: How Brainspotting Helped a D1 Volleyball Player Overcome Her Mental Block on Serves

A Division I volleyball player worked through her serving block with Brainspotting and an out-of-session mental conditioning program after earlier counseling and sport psychology had not helped. It took slightly more than the average number of sessions, and she returned to serving at a high level. This case combines several athletes’ experiences, and results vary.

This case combines the experiences of several athletes I have worked with, and identifying details have been changed. I will refer to the athlete as Kylie.

Kylie had several sport injuries in high school, including two concussions and an ACL tear. She had also been in a car accident in early childhood that left her in a wheelchair for several months. During her freshman year at a Power Four university, before she started working with me, she began having significant problems with her serve. She noticed muscle tension, sweaty hands, a racing heart, and temperature changes in her forehead before serving. She was referred to the university’s sport psychologist and the university counseling center but saw no improvement. They gave her the following strategies:

  • daily journaling to write down positive affirmations

  • create reminders to focus on the positive experiences within the competition

  • when anxiety arises, take 10 deep breaths using box breathing

  • spend more time focusing on the controllables and ignore the past

  • visualize positive serve outcomes

  • consider quitting the sport

 
 

After multiple sessions with no success, her coach and family reached out to me to get her started on her mental training. One of the primary interventions I used was Brainspotting. Brainspotting has two main approaches: activation and resourcing.

  • Activation can be a faster approach where athletes focus on the thoughts and feelings that cause distress. This conditions their brain to be desensitized to negative emotions and negative thoughts surrounding the sport movement.

  • Resourcing, on the other hand, has athletes spend more time focused on calming their nervous system while visualizing negative sports thoughts. This approach allows athletes to be grounded while processing uncomfortable thoughts and emotions.

  • Both approaches can work well, and some athletes respond better to one than the other depending on their needs.

For Kylie, we went with a resource model. During the sessions I would have her first identify where she felt most calm in her body (oftentimes it was her feet), and then we would find the eye positions that helped her focus on her feet the most while processing her negative sport experiences and injury history. She would visualize the bad serves that resulted in sports humiliations as well as some of her previous injuries. The sessions were hard on her, especially early on, and she usually left them drained but noticeably lighter. While there were some initial setbacks in our work (good performances followed by really bad performances), the tension, sweating, and racing heart she felt before serving slowly began to fade. Over time, the anxiety turned into excitement, and she was able to consistently serve the ball with hardly any errors and perform with confidence. She also reported that if she made a mental error or had a setback, she could regain her composure incredibly fast and reset quicker than ever before. If you would like more details about what Brainspotting sessions are like, I encourage you to check out my step-by-step process using this intervention with athletes.

 

Volleyball players celebrating overcoming their mental blocks

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Volleyball Serving Mental Blocks

 

A volleyball in the air after a serve

 

When Should a Parent Get Help for a Volleyball Serving Mental Block?

Get help when her serve holds up in practice but keeps breaking down in matches after her coach has worked on it and routines and pressure drills have not changed anything. If she plans to play in college, start sooner, because regular mental training prepares her for that level of pressure. A Certified Mental Performance Consultant (CMPC) or licensed professional with training in somatic, desensitization-based methods is a good place to start.

For volleyball players who are just playing recreationally, start with her coach, and add a private serving coach if her mechanics break down in practice too. If the coach has already worked on her serve and the answer has become "just relax" or "stop thinking too much," that is the sign she needs a different kind of training. When looking for a sport psychology expert, parents need to make sure that the professional focuses on somatic-based, desensitization protocols. This is because the part of the brain that is producing the mental block response, otherwise known as the subcortical brain region, primarily processes the environment through sensory information. These approaches help bypass the regions of the brain that are not involved with volleyball serving mental blocks and directly access the ones that are.

If this sounds like your player, please understand that there is effective help out there that can help her overcome this incredibly stressful problem. If you are interested in learning more, please check out my services page here. However, if you would like to speak with me directly, use the contact form below or use this link here to directly schedule with me to learn more about my services to see if my approach is possibly what you are looking for. For first time, free discovery calls, they are confidential video calls that run about an hour. I will send you a pre-call assessment to get a better sense of what your athlete is experiencing in order for me to be as prepared as possible for the time we have on the call. We will talk through what is happening at the service line, whether this kind of training fits her situation, and if it does not, I will point you toward someone who does.


Ready to implement these tactics? Book a consultation to see if services are right for you!


Sign up to learn more about new updates with Ben’s practice!

 
 

Check out older Training Report articles below for more resources!

Benjamin Foodman

LCSW, Performance Consultant

Previous
Previous

Why Has My Offensive Lineman Lost His Confidence After Getting Beat in Games?

Next
Next

Why Does My Quarterback Look Great in Practice but Not Like Himself in Games?